Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Trashy 'Family Guy' slams trans culture

Published: Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Updated: Monday, May 17, 2010 21:05

"Family Guy" has long been a cartoon notorious for taking its jokes too far, but most of the time that's ok. Fans of the show approach it with the same mentality "South Park" devotees reserve for their animated obscenity fest of choice: It's meant to be offensive, so suspend your moral standards and enjoy the ride.

But the latest "Family Guy" episode, "Quagmire's Dad," takes the "offensively funny" idea to a whole new level—one where it fails to be funny and just comes off as totally and completely offensive.

The synopsis: Womanizer Glenn Quagmire's father Dan comes to Quahog, R.I. to be honored as a war hero, and during his visit he comes out as a male-to-female transsexual and informs his son that he will be undergoing sexual reassignment surgery during his stay. Typical distasteful "Family Guy" hijinks ensue.

Which is fine, in theory. Transsexuality exists today as perhaps the most taboo sex-oriented topic in America. With gays winning rights across the country, transsexual and transgendered individuals still remain ostracized. The idea of a wildly popular television show giving exposure to the topic of trans-life has so much potential, but after Sunday, it is evident the topic could never have been in worse hands.

At one point, Brian—the Griffin family's anthropomorphic dog—sleeps with Ira (formerly Dan) Quagmire after a night of heavy boozing. When he returns to the Griffin family home the next day, he is beaming about the "incredible" woman he met until genius-baby Stewie informs him that Ira only recently became a woman.

And then Brian vomits on-screen for something like 90 straight seconds. He and Stewie proceed to panic over the fact that he slept with a man—which makes Brian, according to the show's lowbrow moral standard, "sooooo gay." And then the two characters converse in agitated screams about the heinously gay offense Brian committed, and in the process they equate transsexuals with sex offenders, asking why the citizens of Quahog weren't informed about such a sexual deviant moving to town.

To make matters worse, in the scene following Brian's vomiting, Ira confides to his son that he slept with Brian, and Glenn proceeds to storm the Griffin household and beat Brian within an inch of his life, keeping with one of this season's recurring themes: animal abuse.

I shouldn't even have to say it, but I want to make it clear: There is absolutely nothing funny about transsexuality and/or gender identity disorder. And there is likewise nothing funny about animal abuse. I am aware that "Family Guy's" modus operandi is "offend to entertain," but at this point their offending is totally devoid of any redeeming humor value.

By insinuating that transsexuals should be treated like sex offenders and put on registries in communities, "Family Guy" has crossed the line from offensive to abusive. I am not transsexual or transgendered, but I know people who are, and I can only imagine how they must feel watching this show persecute them under the guise of entertainment.

Ignoring the fact that the episode completely misrepresents gender identity disorder and transsexual/transgender issues in general—it makes it seem as though sexual reassignment surgery is an instantaneous procedure, when in reality it is often preceded by years of hormone therapy and counseling—"Quagmire's Dad" grievously brands the trans community as disgusting and "unnatural."

Does that sound funny to you?

Matthew may be reached at copy@su-spectator.com

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

5 comments

Anonymous
Wed Jun 2 2010 17:44
Its because Family Guy is being realistic. Feeling like a woman in man's body and wanting to be with other men is gay. Transgender is the most ridiculous concept ever. Getting a sex change does NOT change your gender, it just gives you "sexual organs" (If you can actually call them that) that do not work. It's sick. If you don't like the cartoon, don't watch it. You can't insult someone for being disgusted by something so ridiculously revolting without turning yourself into hypocrite
Lulu
Tue May 25 2010 04:06
I am trans-identified, and going through hormonal transition. I found it funny, depicting the misunderstanding of the masses. I am disappointed that the masses think such things, and that it is then displayed without much discussion to bring another perspective in. I personally dislike vomiting, so that piece didn't carry the same way in my eyes. For me, the episode's content is educational of what I should anticipate from people. Oddly it was re-affirmed by a woman on the street today before I saw it on the Adult Swim first air of it tonight. She said that people who get sex changes are sick, and followed it up with the bible, citing that G*d didn't make men to be with men or women with women, as there is no reproduction possible. G*d had said to go forth and multiply she mentioned.
If people learn from this to think such things, then it is truly a shame indeed. It doesn't mean that the show can't be redeemed though. Responsibility and accountability should be taken in the future to not make transgender oppression the payload of their jokes.
Anonymous
Thu May 20 2010 12:36
I'm sorry, but that episode was a riot. As for the dog beating, is it really animal abuse when Brian can talk. Oh, you failed to berate the hilarious Mr McFarland's "recurring theme" of beastiality - is that life style ok? Or, OMG, they let a dog babysit a toddler. Look, if you can't laugh at yourself, just don't watch. I am a devout Catholic and he has gone over the line in my mind on that subject. But I don't write an article about it - I turn it off or walk out of the room for that scene. Three key words: IT'S A CARTOON!!!!
CKCH
Mon May 17 2010 15:23
I agree with Boo. That's what I got from it too. Definitely making fun of idiots who say such stupid things ABOUT transgendered and transsexual individuals.
Boo
Fri May 14 2010 07:04
For the most part it seemed like they were trying to satirize cis people's idiotic reactions to trans people. And actually doing not too bad a job of it, until the Brian vomiting part leaped way over the line (not least which because they were recycling literally the same joke from the Cleveland Show). From McFarland's earlier statements about the show, it seems he meant well, but a well meaning idiot is still and idiot. And incidentally, if you're going to write a column defending trans people, please try to get the pronouns right.






log out