Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Bodies not meant to be on display in such a manner

Published: Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Updated: Thursday, November 12, 2009 01:11

The human body is a beautiful thing. It is an elaborate and beautiful piece of machinery that humans all over the world are trying to learn more about.

I will not deny the fact that "Bodies… The Exhibition" is one such way humans can get to know more about the intricate inner workings of their bodies. Premier Exhibitions has redesigned its exhibit but claims the purpose for its second run in Seattle remains the same: to connect people with what is inside all of us.

While those that have seen the "Bodies" exhibit have called it "fascinating" and "educational," I have reservations about calling the exhibit anything but morbid and disgusting.

The exhibit has stirred up controversy wherever it travels, garnering attention from those that call it a freak-show and those that question how the bodies were attained.

While "Bodies" and every other traveling cadaver exhibit are adamant about the fact that the bodies in use were either "unclaimed" or donated to science, there are still those that question these statements. It has been no secret that many of the bodies come from China, and Chinese Human Rights Activists have been raising questions about the plastinated remains since the exhibits started.

While executives at Premier Exhibitions strongly deny using the bodies of executed prisoners or of anyone that died of unnatural causes, former employees that provide bodies to such companies recount tales of going on "body runs" where the bodies of executed prisoners are sold for about $200.

All body-attaining controversy aside, such grotesque display of a human body disturbs me in many ways. While some will make the argument that people in the U.S. donate their bodies to science every day, their bodies are not made into models that travel the country making money for a corporation. Those that donate their bodies to science in China are probably not aware they will be plastinated and travel the world.

There are much better, less morbid and less money-hungry ways to study human anatomy. Using the bodies of human beings in such a grotesque and greedy way is something to be ashamed of. If I were to donate my remains to science, I would hope it would go toward research, not so I could be someone's Sunday afternoon entertainment.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

5 comments

bury me deep, no displaying me
Wed Nov 25 2009 16:48
Dead Chinese aside, your innate sense that it is immoral--has anyone thought to consult the Church on this one. Read its beautiful defense of the dignity of the human person, the human body and the need for that resultant dignity to be protected after death too. If you go about giving us your own thoughts on this you'll find you just reinvented the wheel, there is "nothing new under the sun" and mater ecclesiae has "been down" on this long before you and your homies opined in on it. Stil though, a very good article.
Joe Tynan
Fri Nov 20 2009 22:24
If you choose not to go to Bodies, do it because of the unethical means of getting the bodies they show - not for the supposed "unethical" displaying of said bodies. It's never wrong to educate folks on how their own bodies work, and nothing works better as an educational tool than the real thing. It's a shame that Bodies...The Exhibition chose to obtain "volunteers" who didn't volunteer. THAT is the unjustice.
Seattle Gal
Sun Nov 15 2009 00:43
From the front page of Premier Exhibition's website - Bodies NY Disclose: "This exhibit displays human remains of Chinese citizens or residents which were originally received by the Chinese Bureau of Police. The Chinese Bureau of Police may receive bodies from Chinese prisons. Premier cannot independently verify that the human remains you are viewing are not those of persons who were incarcerated in Chinese prisons.
This exhibit displays full body cadavers as well as human body parts, organs, fetuses and embryos that come from cadavers of Chinese citizens or residents. With respect to the human parts, organs, fetuses and embryos you are viewing, Premier relies solely on the representations of its Chinese partners and cannot independently verify that they do not belong to persons executed while incarcerated in Chinese prisons." So why is Seattle showing desecrated cadavers of prisoners? For education?
Nicole K
Thu Nov 12 2009 13:44
Hi Taylor, thanks for your article. Our organization has been working to raise awareness on this issue for quite some time. There is strong evidence to suggest that the bodies used for these exhibitions are sourced from executed prisoners in China. China executes more people annually than all other countries in the world combined, and the criminal justice system is set up in such a way that a fair trial is all but impossible. In addition to selling bodies for exhibitions like these, the Chinese government also harvests the organs from executed prisoners for transplants. Although the government claims that the prisoners give consent, any kind of consent in such a criminal justice system is dubious at best, and many families report that they were never told that their loved ones' bodies would be used in such a way. The state of New York has already passed regulations to restrict the display of bodies without consent, and the state of Hawaii has recently enacted similar laws. We urge you and your readers to visit www.laogai.org to learn more about the death penalty and organ harvesting in China, and to write to your state representatives to demand that they prohibit the display of these bodies without consent. Nicole Kempton, Washington Director, Laogai Research Foundation, Washington, DC
Rochelle LeMieux
Wed Nov 11 2009 20:44
Thank you Taylor for bringing attention to this extremely over-ignored topic!
I am really disappointed that Seattle University students aren't more adamant about opposing this exhibit due to the large amount of publicity around the controversy of harvesting bodies. Premier Exhibits, the company that supplies Bodies...The Exhibition has been unable to provide any documentation for the people they use for display. These bodies were not donated! And as you said, there is reason to believe that the company was involved in buying bodies of executed political prisoners off the black market.
I am completely shocked by the indifference the Seattle University community, a community that claims to value justice and human rights, shows toward this exhibit.
Whatever the educational value, it is not proportional to supporting a company known for exploiting a terrible system from a government known for killing people without much cause. The reason the bodies weren't "claimed" is because the relatives could be killed for associating themselves with the political prisoner. Seattle University students should re-think their priorities. And if its "education" you want, try "Body Worlds" the original exhibit that has full documentation for every single one of its DONATED bodies.
However, you make a good point in saying we should be showing more respect for the dead than commercially profiting off a human body on display.
Hopefully people will re-think their values after they read your article.






log out